Beauty Lists

20 Things That Make No Sense About Outlander

20 Things That Make No Sense About Outlander

It’s straightforward to fall in love with the fantasy of Outlander. With many profound characters, scenes, and private journeys, it’s grow to be a standout present with a deserved loyal following. Nonetheless, with such a posh historic timeline and collection of magical parts, there are sure to be some obtrusive flaws. As we comply with Claire and Jamie on an epic journey via time and lots of various settings, questions begin to bubble up. It’s weird how Claire will get away with sure issues, and the way some storylines by no means attain a full decision, however not all characters act in response to logic, both. Most of all, the component of time journey has heads spinning, and the way it works precisely stays partly unanswered.

None of those issues take away from Jamie and Claire’s love story, or the richness of the characters themselves, although. Nothing can cease invested followers from appreciating this thrilling present because it dares to step outdoors the set and enterprise into real-world landscapes and voyages. However, we nonetheless have to take a look at it with a eager eye, and there are undoubtedly sufficient inaccuracies and weird decisions to pinpoint. Hopefully, all might be revealed in the long run. The present hasn’t caught up with the books, and the collection of novels itself just isn’t but completed. Even so, it appears nothing can erase or rectify a couple of of the next errors, however perhaps, you can also make sense of a few of these, so in case you have any doubtless solutions, make sure to tell us! Listed here are 20 Things That Make No Sense About Outlander:

Proceed scrolling to maintain studying

Click on the button under to start out this text in fast view

Begin Now

20 Jamie and Claire cherrypick their modifications to historical past

It stays unclear whether or not or not Jamie and Claire have the facility to rework historical past. It could possibly be that they will solely alter small occasions, however not massive ones just like the tragic defeat of the Scots on the battle of Culloden. Nevertheless, we nonetheless don’t know for positive concerning the collection’ guidelines relating to the alteration of previous occasions, but, this doesn’t cease the protagonists from making an attempt to yield sure outcomes.

For one factor, Claire is adamant that Mary Hawkins should marry Black Jack Randall, since she is aware of Frank won’t ever be born if this doesn’t occur. However, after seeing what Randall did to Jamie, and even herself, it’s shocking that Claire would let harmless Mary close to him (not to mention attempt to make them get married). We now have to marvel the place the logic is in a few of these extra egocentric selections.

19 There’s no butterfly impact

Outlander season 3 finale, Claire and Jamie

The main target of Outlander is clearly on the story and never essentially the consequences of time journey, but when we’re getting choosy, there’s rather a lot lacking in that space. The butterfly impact is the concept a particularly small change may cause large penalties down the road. However, when Claire returns to the current, there’s are not any modifications to the world or the best way she lives her life. It’s comprehensible that Claire did not succeed at making drastic modifications to historical past, like the result of Culloden, however once you tamper with the previous, there’s sure to be some penalties.

In addition to, with on a regular basis vacationers that aren’t even proven, there needs to be plenty of chaos being created. Because the present isn’t truly sci-fi, it’s forgivable that this isn’t part of the plot, nevertheless it nonetheless doesn’t make sense.

18 Claire by no means makes positive Jamie is admittedly gone

Was anybody else annoyed when Claire resigns herself to completely staying in her personal time after she returns? She believes Jamie had met his demise at Culloden, however by no means goes again by way of the stones to make certain. It made sense to attend till Brianna was born, however it’s unusual that over the course of 20 years, Claire by no means thought to return. She might have simply gone again to Craigh na Dun, even simply to see Jamie’s household and get some closure.

It takes historic affirmation of Jamie’s existence for Claire to take the leap again in time. She was enjoying it protected, however as Jamie’s once-in-a-lifetime love, it doesn’t make sense for her to surrender so simply.

17 Claire meets Geillis a number of occasions, however hardly another time vacationers

Geillis’ story appeared to be intertwined with Claire’s over the course of three seasons. Although Geillis turned out to be fairly depraved, it was tremendous fascinating to find the journey of one other time traveler. On the similar time, it makes us marvel why we don’t see extra alongside the best way. The stones are undoubtedly not Claire’s secret, and there appears to be many factors of entry into the previous. You’d assume these wanderers can be far and wide.

Claire has observed the occasional vaccine scar in others, or the tooth fillings in a cranium in Fraser’s Ridge. But, she doesn’t discover anybody to share her personal journey with aside from Geillis. It’s additionally fishy that no time vacationers discover Claire is from the longer term both, since she doesn’t disguise her intelligence about sure topics.

16 Jamie married Laoghaire, however she threatened Claire’s life

This one can barely be justified if we’re to consider Jamie nonetheless carried a torch for Claire all these years. Once we first meet Laoghaire, she is mad with jealousy and tries to finish Claire. She was by no means a likable character, and Jamie by no means had an actual attraction to her. It appeared like he wouldn’t have the ability to transfer on from Claire in any respect, and wouldn’t even assume to marry once more.

Laoghaire needs to be the oddest selection he might have picked. Although a part of the choice needed to do together with her daughters, he quickly leaves them anyway. This plot choice in all probability sought to gasoline the drama of Claire’s return greater than something.

15 Claire is ready to go away her daughter for good

After all the things Claire did to guard Brianna, it simply doesn’t add up that she can be ready to by no means see her once more, and it doesn’t take an excessive amount of convincing for Claire to enterprise again into the previous to seek out Jamie after she discovers he is alive. In fact Brianna is a younger grownup at this level who can care for herself, however that doesn’t low cost her and Claire’s tight relationship.

It might make extra sense for Claire to go away if she deliberate to return sooner or later, even briefly. Nevertheless, the present makes it appear to be it’s all or nothing this time, at the very least in Claire’s eyes. She goes by way of the stones absolutely believing she’s leaving her daughter behind, which we might by no means anticipate from such a motherly determine.

14 Murtagh accepts the reason about Claire’s time journey

Jamie and Claire clearly felt it needed to inform Murtagh about Claire’s journey via time, however whereas it was essential for Jamie to know, it may need been much less so in Murtagh’s case. Additionally, it makes even much less sense that he took it so properly, shortly accepting the truth that Claire lived via a lot of the 20th century. The one questions he asks are concerning the consequence of the Jacobite rising and his personal destiny.

It might make sense if Murtagh had a background in Druidry or another Celtic mysticism like different characters, however he doesn’t appear to be the sort to consider in magic. Seeing as Jamie’s circle of relatives nonetheless doesn’t know, telling Murtagh didn’t appear completely crucial to start with.

13 We by no means see a lot of the unique forged after Culloden

Most of what made Outlander such a mesmerizing present was the Scottish world Claire falls into, and naturally, the individuals she meets alongside the best way. But, that is principally dissolved after the loss at Culloden as lots of our favourite characters meet their ends there. It might have been this manner within the books, however it simply doesn’t make sense from a writing standpoint to drop so many characters directly. There needed to be some amongst Jamie’s clan who survived the battle, proper?

It’s true that many followers miss not solely the gorgeous Highlands, but in addition the charisma and familiarity of the unique forged. Fortunately, we meet Murtagh once more in North Carolina, nevertheless it makes us marvel if others survived and simply weren’t talked about once more.

12 Claire and Jamie discover themselves in riches throughout their travels

Everyone knows Jamie had some standing in Scotland, however it’s a bit questionable that he all the time has associates in excessive locations regardless of the place he goes. For instance, they don’t simply go to France, they find yourself on the lavish courtroom of Versailles; in America, Jamie’s aunt owns an enormous property on a plantation referred to as River Run, and in Jamaica, they find yourself on the governor’s extravagant social gathering.

For a lot of the collection to date, cash appears to be no object of their travels. That is, till they determine to create their very own settlement in America at Fraser’s Ridge. It makes for some lovely units, however these extraordinary alternatives wouldn’t occur for any Scotsman!

11 No one questions Claire’s trendy surgical expertise

Claire’s character wouldn’t be the identical with out her superior means carry out numerous varieties of surgical procedure. As a surgeon from the 1960s, she’s a completely distinctive sort of heroine who persistently saves the day. It’s simply bizarre that she brazenly does these very concerned operations in the midst of the 18th century.

In fact, she typically faces resistance when making an attempt to heal individuals because of her gender, however nobody questions the place she discovered these methods, a few of which certainly haven’t been invented but. Particularly since she refers to herself solely as a healer, we’d anticipate extra characters to be stunned when she whips out a knife and begins the surgical procedure. As grateful as her sufferers could also be, these situations ought to possible increase a couple of extra eyebrows.

10 Roger leaves Brianna alone in a unique century

The results are dire when Roger abandons Brianna within the 18th century, which continues to be unfamiliar to her. They get in a single battle and she or he asks him to go away, however that doesn’t imply he truly ought to! In any case, he had simply discovered her they usually had been married that very same day. The entire thing units up the harrowing destiny that awaits Brianna, however it’s means out of character for Roger to do that.

Even Brianna wanting him to go away was fairly silly. She nonetheless hadn’t discovered her mother and father, and Roger was the one different individual she might belief because the two shared the identical secret. No matter the disagreements, this couple ought to have been clinging to one another in such a dangerous setting.

9 Claire saves many lives, however it doesn’t alter the longer term

Overlook the butterfly impact; reworking the whole course of individuals’s lives has to vary the longer term! Claire typically saves individuals who in any other case would have handed on a sure day. It’s often the case that there’s no approach they might have survived with out her surgical expertise, and she or he’s often in the correct place on the proper time. She by no means provides up the chance to save lots of a life, even when her affected person is somebody who’s executed her hurt.

Perhaps, this time journey thriller has one thing to do with the truth that issues have been all the time meant to occur that means. She might have been destined to assist all of them alongside, however both approach, it makes your mind harm!

eight Frank and Claire’s relationship

Caitriona Balfe (Claire Randall Fraser), Tobias Menzies (Frank Randall)- Outlander 301

It’s not extraordinary for couples to remain collectively after the love is gone, however Frank and Claire have had a a lot rockier street than that. Claire actually disappeared, fell in love with one other man in a unique time interval, and returned carrying his baby. Frank and Claire one way or the other put this apart and made the choice to boost Brianna, which is all properly and good, however the truth that this association lasts 20 years is questionable.

They did plan to divorce, however solely after Frank discovers that Claire will return to the previous for Jamie. Didn’t he already know she was nonetheless in love with him, and all the time can be? It appeared like this was a situation of the connection that they each needed to make peace with for Brianna’s sake. So, why is it shocking many years later?

7 The unclear guidelines of time journey

Outlander has a unique model of time journey, however its guidelines aren’t precisely clearly laid out. When 20 years cross in Claire’s time, we’re apparently presupposed to know that this additionally means 20 years have handed within the time she left. That is why she’s distraught when she returns from Culloden and realizes Jamie is gone eternally, however it’s by no means revealed why she will’t return additional. The time durations appear to run parallel to one another, however why from this one level? And since there are different time vacationers, would they’ve totally different previous time durations akin to theirs?

Not one of the characters are phased by this both, or try to determine precisely what the deal is. How did Claire even know for positive that, if she have been to return by way of the stones, it wouldn’t be to the precise level that she left off?

6 Jamie and Claire didn’t use Claire’s information to keep away from Culloden

Jamie and Claire made a valiant effort to cease the battle of Culloden from occurring, however once they fall brief, they nonetheless act like there’s no escape. Although it’s admirable of Jamie to need to battle a battle that’s a sure loss, it tears aside his relationship with Claire. They knew the precise date of the battle, but, didn’t have a plan to save lots of themselves and their unborn daughter.

When it was turning into clear that nothing they did might change the course of historical past, it might have been sensible to make use of their assets to reside a full, joyful life elsewhere. As an alternative, Jamie caught together with his countrymen, but in addition made positive his daughter wouldn’t have the prospect to develop up together with her true father.

5 Jamie doesn’t defeat Jack Randall on the earliest alternative

Jamie might have executed extra than simply rescue Claire at Fort William. Aside from personally seeing Randall threaten his spouse, Jamie ought to have felt justified to get rid of him for different causes. Understanding what Randall had executed to Jamie beforehand needed to be greater than sufficient motivation to finish him proper then and there, and he definitely had the chance.

As an alternative, Randall appeared to have 9 lives as he got here again time and time once more to wreak extra havoc in Jamie’s story. In fact, this gave us extra motion scenes and stored the primary antagonist within the plot for an additional season, however nonetheless, this scene may have you shouting on the TV asking Jamie to only pull the set off.

four Claire’s brief mood doesn’t sometimes get her in hassle

Claire is a blunt and opinionated individual, however she additionally goes so far as to explode in bouts of anger. She has no drawback swearing at officers and high-ranking people in all types of conditions. Although we love this about Claire and respect her talking up for what’s proper, it simply doesn’t make sense that she doesn’t face extra penalties.

In any case, that is the 18th century, and other people wouldn’t be used to widespread codes of conduct being ignored, particularly by a lady. Sadly, the qualities that make Claire such a terrific heroine are additionally problematic on the subject of believability. Lots of the time, characters are merely amused by her outbursts.

three Jamie doesn’t ask about what the longer term is like

Jamie and Claire in Outlander season 4

Given the prospect, wouldn’t anybody need to know what’s happening two-hundred years sooner or later? Jamie has a obscure concept of Claire’s time interval, however in actuality, an individual on this state of affairs can be craving all types of particulars. Even when Claire brings issues up, like saying she’s been vaccinated so she will’t get sure illnesses, Jamie doesn’t query her additional.

It’s not essential to Jamie and Claire’s private story, nevertheless it’s exhausting to consider he wouldn’t need to know all of the transformations and advances Claire has witnessed. Come on, Jamie, she’s lived via a world warfare! She has a wealth of data nobody has been tapping into, aside from to resolve fast considerations.

2 The Druids weren’t a key a part of the story in any case

The dance of the Druids enticed us into the magic of the Outlander collection. When Claire steps by way of the stones for the primary time, they’re performing their ritual that supposedly created the circumstances for time journey. It appeared for a very long time that characters would wish some kind of supernatural ritual to move by means of the stones, and Geillis even thought she wanted a sacrifice.

As we see extra characters return in time, it turns into clear that nothing on such an enormous scale is required. Roger and Brianna do exactly positive getting by means of carrying gems, and supposedly might have inherited the power. It’s unlucky that we misplaced a few of the Celtic magic that added a particular aspect to the story, and for no obvious cause.

1 Jamie’s survival price

Jamie’s power of character is one cause why we admire him a lot, however realistically, the variety of occasions he’s escaped harmful conditions is unreal! To call a number of, he’s survived two days of whipping, the enduring battle of Culloden, operating from the British troopers, illness outbreaks, and quite a few shut calls in each Jamaica and America. His potential to get himself out of hazard rivals any superhero.

Jamie is intelligent and expert, however we’ve got to recollect he’s nonetheless only a man. The collection undoubtedly couldn’t stay with out one in every of its major protagonists, however this type of resiliency isn’t all that believable.

What points of Outlander do not add up for you? Tell us within the feedback!

!perform(f,b,e,v,n,t,s)
if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=perform() n.callMethod?
n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments);
if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n;n.push=n;n.loaded=!zero;n.model=’2.zero’;
n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!zero;
t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];
s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window, doc,’script’,
‘https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js’);
fbq(‘init’, ‘297467373958238’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);
if((window.location.href.indexOf(“utm_source”)!=-1))
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘ViewContent’);

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.10”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.10”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));